#289: THE NUMBERS THAT CAN NEVER BE COUNTED.
- Jul 6
- 2 min read
#289: THE NUMBERS THAT CAN NEVER BE COUNTED. Still another fine example of a book which snuck up on me from behind and jumped into my hands: A Hundred Movements for a Fan, poems by Paul Claudel. In the nineteenth century, a new enthusiasm in France for Japanese culture led to the discovery and collection of that country’s beautifully painted paper fans: every lady had to have one. The poet Stéphane Mallarmé (who in his spare time edited a magazine extolling the new luxury goods) got into the habit of making up quatrains to decorate fans for his wife and wives of his artistic cohorts: a number of these survive, and can be seen at the Mallarmé Museum in Vulaines-sur-Seine. That, as far as I’d known, was a far as this sub-sub-genre had ever gone, so running across this collection by Claudel was a complete surprise to me. Claudel, like a number of European poets (as well as the Chilean poet Pablo Neruda and the Mexican Octavio Paz), ended up in Asia via the diplomatic service: he spent over four years in Japan, survived the Tokyo earthquake in’23, and created the still-existing Maison Franco-Japonaise in Tokyo. Japan became part of his mindset and his work, as did India with Octavio Paz. In his preface to this collection, Claudel, like so many poets, cannot resist trying to tell us what he has done, talking about “a few words, freed from the harness of syntax and joined once again by the whiteness of their simultaneity alone, a phrase made up of relations!”—which frankly I find less than helpful. He also, in the poems, breaks up phrases and individual words with odd lineation, which he is quite certain means something very deep, which I take the liberty of doubting. But the poems themselves are delightful and charming, and sometimes even, yes, mysterious. Suggested to him by the haiku form, they are sort of like the haiku’s first cousin:
Tu m’appelles la Rose You call me the Rose
dit la Rose says the Rose
mais si tu savais but if you knew
mon vrai nom my real name
je m’ effeuillerais I would shrivel
aussitot at once
Bruit de l’eau Noise of water
sur de l’eau on water
ombre shadow
d’une feuille of a leaf
sur on
une autre feuille another leaf
I don’t always expect to go to French poetry for works of fancy, especially in the shadow of Claudel’s somber religious dramas, but there you are: another rabbit chance and talent have pulled out of the hat.
Il faut qu’il y ait In a there must be
dans le poëme poem a number
un nombre that
tel stops it ever
qu’il empêche being counted
de compter
A Hundred Movements for a Fan, by Paul Claudel. Translated by Andrew Harvey and Iain Watson. Quartet Books, 1992. The French edition, Cent phrases pour éventails, from Poésie Gallimard, contains a good deal of Claudel’s quirky and charming calligraphy.
Several of Mallarmé’s éventail verses are in Henry Weinfield’s splendid translation of the Collected Poems, published by California. The website for the Mallarmé Museum (www.musee-mallarme.fr) shows not only the verses but several of the fans as well.


Comments