top of page
Search

88: THE DOCUMENTS IN THE CASE

#88: THE DOCUMENTS IN THE CASE. “Union of religious sentiments begets a surprising confidence, and ecclesiastical establishments tend to great ignorance and corruption; all of which facilitates the execution of mischievous projects,” wrote James Madison in 1774. Among the livelier efforts of the religious right’s mischievous projects has been the retroactive assertion of the United States as a “Christian nation”—Christian not by statistical affiliation but by legal establishment. The project has only been able to go forward with a kind of intellectual shoddiness, disregard for historical fact and plain deceit that a decade or two ago would have been considered incredible. But ignorance and corruption, like the poor, are always with us. (Please keep in mind that Madison was not some Satanic card-playing heathen but a post-graduate student of theology at Princeton, under John Witherspoon.) So information is what’s needed, and Forrest Church’s splendid and too-little-known anthology The Separation of Church and State: Writings on a Fundamental Freedom by America’s Founders (Beacon Press, 2004) can be your reference, your inspirational reading and your handful of aces in an argument. If your debaters are too little impressed by the words of Washington, John Adams, Jefferson and Madison, hit them with the ministerial insistences of (Norwich-born) Isaac Backus, John Leland or Caleb William. Then slam-dunk them with the Senate-ratified, John Adams-autographed eleventh article of the Treaty of Tripoli: “The government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion.” Actually and interestingly, Church reminds us that on the issue of liberty of conscience there was a collaboration between men who “stressed freedom from the dictates of organized religion” and those who “demanded freedom for religion.” Facts these days may not win an argument—were we talking about ignorance and corruption?—but here they are if you want ‘em, in one pocket-sized and well-printed volume.

Recent Posts

See All

#219. CHECKING THE BOOKS. Princeton University Press over the last few years has been publishing an interesting series, “The Lives of the Great Religious Books,” short popular “biographies” of how t

#218. GIVING THE PEOPLE WHAT THEY WANT. Movie stars rarely seem to have more fun onscreen than when they’re making fun of other movie stars, and few recent films had more fun with this topic than th

#217. FERNANDO PESSOA, EDMUND WILSON, YEHUDA AMICHAI. The Portuguese writer Fernando Pessoa is an easy darling to everyone who writes about literature, because he’s got such a great and vivid story.

bottom of page